NATIONAL Court has rejected suspended National Airports Corporation (NAC) managing director Rex Kiponge’s application to review the decision on his suspension.
COURT POINTS OUT SHORTCOMINGS ON KIPONGE'S SUSPENSION
The National Main Stories, December 19, 2022.By BEVERLY PETER
NATIONAL Court has rejected suspended National Airports Corporation (NAC) managing director Rex Kiponge’s application to review the decision on his suspension.
Deputy Chief Justice Ambeng Kandakasi said NAC had declared that it was a private entity and not a public authority open for judicial review.
“Kiponge was employed under contract employment and he was only suspended and not terminated which means his contract is still in existence,” Justice Kandakasi said.
“NAC is a company registered under the Company Act and is not a public authority open for judicial review. If there is a change in the registration that NAC is a public entity, then the counsels must provide evidence to show.”
Kiponge sought to review the National Executive Council decision of Dec 5, and published gazettal notice on Dec 7.
The decision to suspend Kiponge — pursuant to the amended Civil Aviation Act 2022 — was passed by Parliament on Dec 2.
Counsel Noel Ako representing Kiponge said the Act provided that the minister could suspend the NAC managing director and appoint a senior person within NAC to act in the next three months.
Ako said Civil Aviation Minister Walter Schnaubelt did not follow the Act by appointing a senior person as the acting managing director.
“Joseph Tupiri was a person outside NAC,” he added.
Ako said Kiponge was also denied natural justice because Schnaubelt did not give him an advanced notice to inform him of the decision.
Justice Kandakasi said Kiponge may have an arguable case as far as the process to suspend and appointing the managing director.
“But does he have standing to come by way of judicial review and the legal foundation for the court to rely on?” he asked.
Counsel Dan Kakaraya, also representing Kiponge, said Kiponge had standing to make the application because his contract of employment was affected by the Act.
“Acting on the amended Act nullifies and voids Kiponge’s employment contract,” he said.
Justice Kandakasi said: “The Act has already been passed and rightly or wrongly it is a law.” He said the counsels did not provide any case law to support their case and dismissed the proceeding.
He said there were cases in which the court had already determined that private entities were not open for judicial review.
He added that Kiponge’s employment contract could only be affected after the determination of his suspension.
“Until then, his contract still remains and he is still employed by NAC,” he said.
He further added that the counsels did not provide any case law to support their case and dismissed the proceeding.
Read more news and stories here. Watch online news and documentaries about Papua New Guinea here.
Time is Money: Why Homeownership Can't Wait. Don't delay homeownership! Property values rise, rent is lost, and equity grows. Start now for financial freedom.
Samuel, a young father and husband, is battling a brain tumor and needs your help. He needs urgent surgery to remove a growing brain tumor. Seizures are becoming more frequent, and he’s racing against the clock. Donate now to give him a chance at life. Help and give him the chance to see his children […]
Seeking Kind Donation: Help Francesca’s mom get life-saving heart surgery in the Philippines. Read more and support! Seeking Donation! Mom Needs Help to Get Life-Saving Heart Surgery in the Philippines – Update. by Francesca Digori Hi everyone, As some of you may know, I recently shared a bit about a personal challenge my family is […]